Hello! As we have been receiving orders at extremely high volumes, we want to ask for your understanding when it comes to placing orders with us. 
We are asking for you to provide us with more time in advance to be able to accommodate your requests for cakes, cupcakes, and more. Our team works extremely hard and are so thankful for all of you. 

We ask for your understanding of the following: 

We ask for at least 3 to 4 days notice for all basic cake orders. (This includes cakes from our Gourmet list, custom cakes with basic fillings and simple buttercream decoration, etc.)
We ask for at least two to three weeks notice for all
SPECIAL cake orders. (This includes Tiered cakes, cakes with Fondant decoration, cakes with detailed designs or scenes, etc.)
We ask for at least 3 to 5 days notice for cupcake and cake pop orders.
We ask for at least three weeks notice for all custom Sugar Cookie orders.

You can give us a call to run your ideas by us at any time; the sooner the better!
Thank you so much for your understanding - we are forever thankful!

Subscribe to our newsletter • Don’t miss out!

Thanks for subscribing!

click here to view our 



click here to view our


Share your experience with us
How long have you been coming to The Pastry Garden?
What type of product do you purchase the most of from us?
Please rate your overall satisfaction with our productVery dissatisfiedA bit dissatisfiedPretty satisfiedSatisfiedVery satisfiedPlease rate your overall satisfaction with our product

Thanks for sharing! We always strive to improve.

We would like to extend a tremendous

thank you to the readers of

Hudson Valley Magazine

for voting us to have

Best birthday cakes

and best bakery!


The Pastry Garden is...

a retail and wholesale bakery known for attention to detail, delectably irresistible recipes, and consistent quality. The staff at Pastry Garden takes great pride in "home grown" traditions, preparing and serving the Hudson Valley's best desserts including gourmet cakes, fancy Italian-style cookies, precious pastries, and more. We are here for all of your baked-goods needs, with production done on premises at the Poughkeepsie Plaza, conveniently located just off Route 9, minutes from the Poughkeepsie Train Station and a short ride north of Fishkill and I84.​

The Pastry Garden opened in December of 1984 as a small retail bakeshop by owners Anthony & Stephanie Principe with one salesperson in a storefront leased from Adams Fairacre Farms in Arlington. Sales demand was strong - more products were created and additional staff was hired. Production was expanded, moving all baking and decorating to its current home at the Poughkeepsie Plaza. Wholesale business began to grow as restaurants and caterers discovered the variety of pastries and cakes that were available for area delivery. Presently, The Pastry Garden has established partnerships with top-rated wedding & special event venues throughout the Hudson Valley. Visit or call us today for all of your baked-goods needs!